what might a healthy community look like?
- Some discussion January 26th, 2021 in chat with friends talking about healthy community prompted me to share these reflections:
- I feel like I tasted a substantial percentage (50%? 70%?) of the Real Community thing in the group I was in in Waterloo for the last 8 years, but compartmentalized away the parts of me that knew something was yet missing, so it felt like the whole thing. Which is an incredible feeling! And has given me a taste for what it feels like to wayfind collectively towards having the whole thing for a whole group, and a clear sense that that's my top priority! So very happy to talk more about this, here or 1-on-1.
- I've been sometimes calling the thing Home.
- And there was something loud in the Waterloo group's frame that was negating at least my sense of Home but also in the way it was doing it was negating the idea that we need to integrate everyone's sense of Home. In principle the Waterloo framework is itself a wayfinding tool for doing that; in practice it had some blindspots that were keeping it stuck, afaict.
- Not to mention that I didn't feel quite at home in the absence of some rationalist memes/norms, though that's personal to me, whereas the many people thing seems more fundamental and universal. Like I guess that maybe wouldn't happen with ancient tribes, but it does happen naturally with small towns. Though also my experience in Waterloo also meant I knew that the rationalist scene wasn't adequately Home either.
- Come to think of it, I grew up in a small town (1400 people; 40-60 minutes away from the next biggest places which were like 10k people) and I actually learned some rare pieces from that about what healthy community looks like. As a kid I would wander around and many adults knew who I was without me having to introduce myself, and if they didn't I could tell them who my parents or grandparents were and they would know me. Also had a bit of the grandparents experience at a summer family church camp my ancestors had gone to for generations, which I wrote about in this song. It helped, I'm sure that my parents & grandparents were both very active in the community, so asymmetrically well-known compared to other adults.
8 linked references
Podcast summaries
With Joe Lightfoot — Podcast with Joe Lightfoot Transcript › Outline of ideas discussed (I'm 'M', Joe is 'J')
- 0:00:34 - 12:55 - Home, what might a healthy community look like?
- 0:00:34 - J invites M to share “any kind of song that is inside of your heart if there's one that is desired to be shared right now”. This leads to M sharing this song:
- 9:20 - 12:54 - What it would look like if I built my own community, using Euvie Ivanova and Mike Gilliland's Smart Village as reference.
- Keywords - brain hemispheres coercion what is coercion? productivity scapegoat Everyone is basically living in a dream mashup of their current external situation & old emotional meanings everyone is constantly overgeneralizing Conversation As Medium make shared or different frames explicit shared train of thought do people naturally self-regulate how deep they're willing to go? commitment/choice is a confused way to relate to stances/mindsets dream mashups Unlocking the Emotional Brain IFS partswork what might a healthy community look like? doing community well The Master and his Emissary intro left hemisphere right hemisphere Behavior: The Control of Perception Perceptual Control Theory Hemisphere DharmaChange doesn't just happenHemispheres & Self-improvement left hemispheres aren't made for interfacing with other people Perceptual Control Theory control systems
- Keywords: NNTD, Home, everyone will constantly point out ways in which things are incomplete, Learning how to trust yourself when all men doubt you, but make allowance for their doubting too, community, what might a healthy community look like?, complaints are sacred: how we affirm our values, protectiveness is damage control, defensiveness = protectiveness, Everyone is basically living in a dream mashup of their current external situation & old emotional meanings, sometimes things need to be said even though they feel like they really really should go without saying, What is Blame?, everything makes sense, there's no way to communicate correctly or incorrectly - there's just what works in context and what doesn't work, apologize in the other person's frame; forgive in your own frame, power dynamics
With Joe Lightfoot — Podcast with Joe Lightfoot Transcript › Outline of ideas discussed (I'm 'M', Joe is 'J')
- 16:38 - 23:51 - Trust Learning how to trust yourself when all men doubt you, but make allowance for their doubting too and its role in creating a healthy community, what might a healthy community look like?
- 47:54 - 56:29 - What if gossip were good? what might a healthy community look like? doing community well blindspot feedback is hard (but possible!)
September 6th, 2021
- impressively relevant to both fractal Home (quite literally) and also to what might a healthy community look like? in the physical sense (lots of cool related links in the thread)
