Malcolm Ocean's roamblog

September 19th, 2020

edited 2020-09-19 · open in Roam
  • re solutions are way harder than problems, I started drafting a tweet but it got long & complex:
    • I regularly remind myself that when people or ideologies say "this is messed up":
      - they're almost always right that *something* is borked
      - they usually have at least a little insight into what
      - no matter how clarifying or mindblowing their description of the problem, 99%+ of proposed solutions are complete nonstarters
    • Maybe another, even shorter way to put this is "Not liking someone's solution doesn't mean that there isn't a problem. Most solutions are junk."
    • Although how I *actually* want to frame it is "just because someone can convince you there's a problem, doesn't mean you have to accept their solution"
    • Here we go:
      • Accepting that something is a problem does not require accepting any proposed solutions.

        99% of described problems are real and important, at least in some sense. 99% of proposed solutions are at best irrelevant and at worst actively would exacerbate things.
      • (tweeted this)